World Economic Forum report on administrative reform and new provinces in Pakistan
The World Economic Forum report explores administrative restructuring in Pakistan to improve governance and decentralise decision-making.

Pakistan’s debate over creating new provinces and smaller administrative units has gained fresh momentum after the World Economic Forum (WEF) outlined several options for restructuring the country’s administrative map to improve governance, decentralise decision-making and bring public services closer to citizens.

In an analysis published on its website on October 9, the WEF’s Centre for Regions, Trade and Geopolitics examined possible models for reorganising Pakistan’s administrative structure as its population continues to grow, potentially reaching 265 million by 2030.

The report, titled What Pakistan Reveals About Administrative Reform for Fast-Growing Populations, argues that administrative boundaries and governing institutions may need to evolve when population growth outpaces the capacity of existing systems.

Pakistan currently has four provinces, with an average population of approximately 60 million people per province. The WEF analysis examines alternative administrative arrangements that could reduce the scale of individual governing units and bring political authority, public budgets and accountability closer to local communities.

However, the report does not prescribe a single model or recommend a definitive number of provinces. Instead, it presents different scenarios and stresses that administrative restructuring must be accompanied by effective institutions, adequate funding and transparent accountability mechanisms.

WEF outlines three models for Pakistan’s administrative restructuring

The WEF analysis presents three broad options for reorganising Pakistan’s administrative geography, each involving different political, financial and governance considerations.

Under the first model, each of the four existing provinces could be divided into four units, creating a total of 16 first-tier governments. This would reduce the average population governed by each unit from approximately 60 million to around 15 million.

A second option would establish between 23 and 25 administrative units, taking population balance and geographical coherence into account.

A third model would build on Pakistan’s existing administrative divisions, potentially creating more than 30 administrative units. According to the analysis, this approach could bring the average population of governing units closer to that of other large federations.

The WEF notes that a smaller number of units could be easier to legislate for and finance, while a larger number could bring administrative capitals, budgets and political authority closer to citizens.

However, establishing additional governments would also involve transition costs and require sufficient administrative capacity to manage institutions, public finances and service delivery.

The report emphasises that the objective should not simply be to increase the number of provinces or administrative units, but to align the scale of government with the needs of the population.

Pakistan’s growing population puts pressure on existing system

Pakistan’s population has increased more than sevenfold since 1951, placing growing demands on public services, infrastructure and administrative institutions.

The WEF analysis argues that when populations expand faster than governing institutions, governments need to reconsider whether their existing administrative arrangements remain suitable for delivering services effectively.

The challenge is particularly visible in Pakistan, where provincial governments oversee large and diverse populations spread across urban centres, rural districts and geographically remote areas.

The report cites Lahore district, with a population of approximately 13 million, and Harnai district in Balochistan, with around 128,000 residents, as examples of the differences that policymakers must accommodate within the same national administrative system.

Such disparities mean that policies designed at provincial capitals must address widely varying local conditions, population sizes and public service requirements.

According to the WEF analysis, bringing decision-making closer to communities could help governments respond more effectively to local needs, provided that administrative authority and resources are also transferred.

28% of Pakistani children out of school, Balochistan faces highest rate

Education disparities provide another indication of the challenges facing Pakistan’s existing governance structure.

The report cites the Planning Commission’s District Education Performance Index, which found that none of the 134 districts assessed reached the “very high” performance category.

Household survey data cited in the analysis show that 28% of children aged between five and 16 are out of school nationally.

The reported provincial rates range from 21% in Punjab to 45% in Balochistan, highlighting substantial differences in educational access across the country.

The WEF analysis links these disparities to the gaps between policymakers and districts, public spending and service delivery outcomes, and administrative authority and accountability.

Smaller governing units could make it easier to identify local priorities and monitor public spending. However, the report cautions that better outcomes would depend on whether the relevant governments possess the authority, funding and institutional capacity to act.

Provincial tax collection remains a major challenge

The WEF report identifies weak provincial revenue mobilisation as a major constraint on governance and public service delivery in Pakistan.

Although provincial governments have assumed significant responsibilities for services, their own-source tax revenues remain limited.

Provincial taxes generated Rs983 billion during the 2024-25 fiscal year, equivalent to less than 0.9% of Pakistan’s gross domestic product, according to the report.

Agriculture presents a particular challenge. The sector accounts for approximately 24% of value added, yet agricultural income taxation has historically generated limited revenue relative to its economic contribution.

The International Monetary Fund estimates the effective tax rate on agriculture at 0.3%, while agricultural income tax receipts have remained below expectations despite increases in tax rates in 2025.

Provincial tax authorities have faced longstanding difficulties, including limited administrative capacity, weak enforcement and inadequate information for identifying taxable agricultural income.

The report says improvements in data-sharing with the Federal Board of Revenue, greater automation and stronger provincial enforcement will be important for addressing these weaknesses.

It also warns that newly created provinces could face the same financial constraints as existing governments if administrative restructuring is not accompanied by reforms to taxation and public financing.

18th Amendment and NFC Award have not brought all decisions closer to citizens

Pakistan has taken major steps towards decentralisation through the 18th Constitutional Amendment and the seventh National Finance Commission Award.

The constitutional amendment devolved significant responsibilities to the provinces, while the NFC Award increased the provinces’ share of federal tax revenues.

However, the WEF analysis argues that decision-making can still remain distant from communities within the provinces themselves.

It suggests that decentralisation should extend beyond provincial capitals, with administrative authority, financial resources and accountability reaching the districts and communities most affected by government policies.

Weak local revenue systems can also undermine accountability by making it harder for citizens to connect the taxes they pay with the public services they receive.

The report argues that greater fiscal proximity, if designed carefully, could strengthen this relationship.

“For a country exposed to floods, water stress, rapid urbanisation and youth employment pressures, proximity is not a luxury; it is part of resilience,” the WEF centre says.

What other countries reveal about creating smaller administrative units

The WEF analysis draws on international experiences to examine how changes to administrative boundaries can affect governance.

Nigeria expanded from three regions at independence to 12 states in 1967 and eventually to 36 states by 1996.

Indonesia increased its number of provinces from 27 in 1991 to 38, while Kenya replaced its eight provinces with 47 elected county governments under a devolved system in 2013.

The report notes that average first-tier populations in Indonesia, Nigeria and Brazil are approximately six million to eight million, substantially below Pakistan’s average of around 60 million across its four provinces.

Kenya’s experience is particularly relevant to the discussion because administrative restructuring was accompanied by changes to political responsibilities and public financing.

Its counties received constitutionally protected responsibilities and formula-based allocations of national revenue, with the distribution formula taking factors such as population and poverty into account.

The analysis also highlights the risks of creating administrative units without ensuring that they have sufficient financial and institutional capacity.

Lebanon, for example, has more than 1,000 municipalities, many of which remain too small and financially weak to deliver services effectively.

The comparisons suggest that changing boundaries alone cannot guarantee better governance. The effectiveness of any new arrangement depends on the institutions, resources and accountability mechanisms supporting it.

New provinces alone will not solve Pakistan’s governance problems

The WEF analysis cautions against treating administrative restructuring as a solution to every governance challenge.

Creating additional provinces could bring government closer to citizens, but it could also increase administrative expenditure and create fragmented institutions if responsibilities and funding arrangements are not clearly defined.

The report identifies capable institutions, transparent fiscal transfers, comparable performance data and incentives for local revenue mobilisation as essential elements of effective reform.

For Pakistan, the debate therefore extends beyond deciding whether to retain four provinces or establish additional ones.

The central question is how to align the size of governing units with population needs while ensuring that each administration has the resources and authority required to deliver essential services.

As Pakistan faces rapid urbanisation, climate-related emergencies, water stress and growing demands for education, healthcare and employment, the WEF analysis places administrative scale at the centre of a wider discussion about decentralisation and public sector reform.

Its findings provide a framework for examining possible changes to Pakistan’s administrative structure, while leaving the choice of any future model to the country’s political and constitutional processes.